How To Negotiate Disagreement Without Giving Up Or Giving In

In today’s age of rising division and polarization, disagreement often feels like a zero-sum game.

Unable or unwilling to negotiate conflict with skill, we ignore it or avoid it for as long as possible; when we are forced to face it, we escalate everyday disagreements and temporary flare-ups as if they’re life-and-death. Neither approach addresses underlying issues, promotes stronger relationships, nor yields satisfying results.

It’s no wonder we try to avoid conflict and have a challenging time finding consensus. Conflict is getting the better of us.

But what if conflict could be reframed—not as an obstacle to be overcome but as an opportunity to forge stronger relationships?

In the new book, Conflict Resilience: Negotiating Disagreement Without Giving Up or Giving In, two former Harvard faculty—internationally-recognized negotiator, mediator and conflict management expert Robert Bordone, a Senior Fellow at Harvard Law School, and leading behavioral neurologist and cutting-edge scientist Joel Salinas, M.D.—show us how we can turn conflict into a win for everyone.

“We teach you how to develop and flex your conflict-resilient muscles and start handling conflict without escalating it, avoiding it, or surrendering your most closely held values or most desirable outcomes,” explain the authors.

“We also explain in easy-to-follow language how our brains and bodies process conflict and teach you surprisingly simple steps, strategies, and best practices on how to emerge from moments of conflict more empowered and with more equanimity."

Conflict resilience is a skillset and mindset that empowers us to sit genuinely with disagreement and grow from it. It involves practical solutions that tap into what’s actually happening in our bodies and our brains during moments of conflict.

Drawing on both powerful neuroscience and advanced conflict management techniques, Bordone and Salinas share genius brain hacks and a groundbreaking three-step framework to navigate conflict, including:

NAME (and dig deep) – to better understand your relationship with conflict, name or diagnose recurring patterns around it. Deeply examining experiences and responses cand rive greater awareness and tolerance to the discomfort of disagreement
EXPLORE (and be brave) – to cultivate genuine curiosity, ask brave questions that explore your deeper motivations, that authentically connect to what you genuinely want
COMMIT (and own the conflict) – engage with conflict constructively, setting the table for a positive, collaborative process. Take responsibility, actively engage in the process, and shape a culture that encourages open discussion about differences.

“As long as human beings interact with each other, there will be conflict. How we embrace, use, mold, and grow with conflict are choices that will make the difference for the world in which we live and, truly, for the security, happiness, and fulfillment of our lives,” say the authors “This process often starts with a tiny first step: when you pause and appreciate, despite all hardship, how startlingly beautiful conflict can be.”

Robert C. Bordone

Joel Salinas, M.D.

The authors share these additional insights with us:

Question: How can leaders/organizations better manage a deeply polarized workplace?

Bordone: Leaders can start by modeling vulnerability—sharing their own uncertainties and biases. Creating spaces for open dialogue and training teams in conflict resilience helps dismantle polarization. Organizations thrive when leaders normalize diverse and even conflicting perspectives.

Question: Most people think conflict is a bad thing and work hard to avoid it. You see it differently. You think conflict needs to be handled directly. Why do you think people avoid or shy away from engaging with it?

Bordone: Conflict feels risky because it’s often handled poorly. People fear losing relationships, their status, or peace of mind. Avoiding it might seem like self-protection, but it creates long-term harm—letting issues fester or escalating them later. When approached with skill, conflict can strengthen relationships and foster creativity, but we need to reframe our mindset about it first.

Question: What is conflict resilience, and how does it differ from conflict resolution?

Bordone: Conflict resilience is the ability to stay present and engaged in disagreement, even when it’s uncomfortable. It’s not to be confused with solving the issue, which is the goal of conflict resolution. It’s instead about learning to sit with the discomfort, staying curious, and navigating tough conversations.

And it’s worth noting that without resilience, resolution is unlikely. That’s because if you can’t tolerate the discomfort of the disagreement, then you can’t get to the point of talking about how to resolve it. And then you are left with either avoiding or fighting.

Question: What key skills are needed to manage conflict effectively?

Bordone: Three critical skills stand out. First, self-awareness—recognizing your triggers and how your emotions affect your reactions.

Second, deep listening—not just hearing words but cultivating a curiosity that can demonstrate a deeper understanding and empathy for their perspective.

Finally, effective assertion—clearly and confidently expressing your perspective with authenticity but also in a way that maximizes the chance that the other can take it in and appreciate your perspective.

Question: How can greater conflict resilience lead to personal growth and better relationships?

Salinas: Conflict resilience helps us lean into tough conversations with curiosity and courage, leading to deeper self-awareness and stronger connections. By staying engaged instead of defensive, we uncover shared understanding and build trust. It’s like working a muscle—the more we practice, the stronger and more adaptable we become.

Question: How can conflict be reframed from an obstacle to an opportunity?

Salinas: Integrating the idea that conflict is an opportunity to learn about yourself and the other and to improve the relationship is a first step to reimagining it as a gift rather than a threat. The fear of engaging in conflict with the other person often causes more damage than the act of engaging those differences with authenticity, curiosity, and courage. That’s why developing conflict resilience is such an important leadership skill.

Thank you to the book’s publisher for sending me an advance copy of the book.

Comments

Book Review: The Elephant In The Room

Diana McLain Smith's new book, The Elephant in the Room , explains how relationships make or break the success of leaders and organizations. It's not a light right. For those who really want to understand relationships, however, this book, based on Smith's clinical research and a wealth of in-depth observational studies, is both insightful and worth the effort. Smith explains that when people click or clash, we typically chalk it up to chemistry and leave it at that. But, she knows there are many dynamics within that relationship that need understanding by a leader to create success. In fact, she says it's possible to identify and analyze the seemingly mysterious ingredients that go into the makings of a relationship. And, given the right tools, it's possible to understand what happens when a relationship forms, and then to actually anticipate what might happen next . That anticipation is critical, claims Smith. Smith also shows read...

Decision-Making Lessons From History

As seen on Public Television, the book, Decisions , by Robert L. Dilenschneider , features vignettes on 23 individuals who made decisions that shaped the world. Each chapter offers practical thinking on how these women and men made decisions. You can use their decision-making skills as guidance at work, in your leadership role, and in your daily life. You’ll learn decision making tips from Harry Truman , Margaret Thatcher , Mohammed Ali , Rachel Carson , Pablo Picasso and others who made decisions during war and peace, and in fields of science, commerce and invention. Author Dilenschneider suggests takeaways about decision-making from each featured historical figure. Some of my favorite decision-making lessons from history and from the book include these: Own your decisions . Be responsible for them and for their implications. Do not be reactionary—that is, making decisions to spite others or because of outside pressure—but do be r...

Q&A With Best Selling Author And Expert Storyteller, Paul Smith

Paul Smith Paul Smith's book, Lead with a Story , is one of the top 10 books I recommend every leader should read. In his book, Paul demonstrates how storytelling is a powerful business tool that can mean the difference between mediocre results and phenomenal success. Since the book was published about three years ago, my admiration for Paul's passion for storytelling and helping to teach people how to effectively tell stories has only but grown. Today, Paul was kind enough to share his thoughts about: that best-selling book how storytelling is growing in the business world his latest book how to use stories during job interviews how Lead with a Story totally changed his carreer 1. How would you summarize the overall reaction to your Lead with a Story book? Any surprises? Paul : Everything is a surprise with your first book. Being a new author, you don’t really know what to expect in terms of book sales, marketing effort...

One Minute Mentoring

Fortunately, I've benefited from having great mentors throughout my career. And, I've have the honor and good fortune to be a mentor, both formally and informally, for various individuals the past few decades. Mentoring is powerful. Both being a mentor. And, being mentored. That's why I became an instant fan of the book, One Minute Mentoring: How to Find and Work With a Mentor -- and Why You'll Benefit from Being One . The book presents a fictional parable about the power of finding, or being, a mentor. In what is about a one- to two-hour read, you'll gain knowledge and easy-to-use tools for how to find and leverage mentoring relationships . Ken Blanchard You'll also learn why developing effective communication and relationships across generations through mentoring can be a tremendous opportunity for companies and individuals alike. Bestselling author, Ken Blanchard, Ph.D . teamed up with Claire Diaz-Ortiz to write One Mi...

Book Review & Highlights: Leadership Conversations

When I read business books, I turn the corner of every page that has something I really like, want to remember and easily reference in the future. Halfway into the 300-page book, Leadership Conversations , I had turned the corners of nearly every fifth pages. So, you can see why I believe this is such a good book. There is so much to learn from Leadership Conversations . It's a must read for today's business leaders. Leaders who are leading multi-generational workforces. And, leaders who want the skills to get promoted and move up the corporate ladder. Authors Alan S. Berson and Richard G. Stieglitz wrote the book because they believe that a leader's most powerful skill is the ability to hold effective conversations . So, in their book, they detail the four types of conversations every leader must effectively master . Conversations that: Buil...

How to Be a Leader – 9 Principles from Dale Carnegie

Today, I welcome thought-leader Nathan Magnuson as guest blogger... Nathan writes : This is it, your first day in a formal leadership role. You’ve worked hard as an individual contributor at one or possibly several organizations. Now management has finally seen fit to promote you into a position as one of their own: a supervisor. You don’t care if your new team is only one person or ten, you’re just excited that now – finally – you will be in charge! Unfortunately the euphoria is short-lived. Almost immediately, you are not only overwhelmed with the responsibilities of a team, but you quickly find that your team members are not as experienced or adroit as you. Some aren’t even as committed. You find yourself having to repeat yourself, send their work back for corrections, and staying late to fill the gap. If something doesn’t change soon, you might just run yourself into the ground. How did something that looked so easy ...

Business And Life Lessons From Entrepreneur Miguel Leal

What I like most about Miguel Leal ’s memoir, aside from its overall compelling and inspiring information, are the business and life lessons he shares. Those lessons are found throughout his recently released memoir, The House That Cheese Built . The book is a quintessential American dream story from a Mexican entrepreneur who shares the tale of building a multi-million-dollar business from scratch, complete with both success and failure, and always a vision of hope. Leal came to the U.S. penniless as a teenager, speaking almost no English; he literally slept in the boiler room of a Wisconsin cheese factory for months before he was caught. Through hard work, grit, and ingenuity Leal would go on to launch his own business. He is widely credited with introducing Mexican cheeses to the U.S. market and grew his company to a multimillion-dollar success story that defined an industry. Yet, like many successful entrepreneurs, Leal’s great successes were matched by a variety of ...

Book Review: Conflict 101

Handling conflict is one of the most difficult things a leader has to deal with. Unfortunately, conflict in the workplace is inevitable. In fact, research shows that 42 percent of a manager's time is spent addressing conflict . And, over 65 percent of performance problems are caused by employee conflicts . Managers new in their leadership role typically have had little to no training on how to deal with conflict. Fortunately, in Susan H. Shearouse's new book, Conflict 101 , you can learn: How conflict is created How we respond to conflict How to management conflict more effectively Shearouse explains that even though conflict is inevitable, it can lead to both growth and progress . "There is little progress that is not preceded by some kind of conflict," says Shearouse. I found particularly helpful in the book the definitions of the following five different types of conflict and then how best to deal with each: Problems to solve Disagreem...

How To Achieve Success Through The Power Of One More

“You are one more intentional thought and action away from discovering your best life,” explains author of the new book, The Power Of One More , by Ed Mylett – released earlier this summer. “You can find your best life by doing ‘one more’ than the world expects from you,” he adds. In his book, he further explains that your individual thoughts and actions you take don’t need to be profound. However, when you compound these small thoughts and actions and stack them up on top of each other, the resulting changes over time are profound. Mylett reveals strategies chapter by chapter and covers goal setting, habits, emotions, relationships, are more. Strategies include those on how to: Slow down time and spot new opportunities Use time to your fullest advantage Find deeper purpose in life Be sure to check out Chapters 15 and 16, which focus on leadership . Within those, Mylett shares his thoughts about leadership: You are a leader if y...

70 Simple Rules For Sensational Service

Flavio Martins ' book, Win The Customer , teaches you 70 simple rules for sensational service . "These can be used as a top-down resource in organizations looking to develop or enhance a service culture," explains Martins. "They can also be used as a resource for individuals who want to transform the way service is handled from the ground up, even when lacking the full commitment and support from organization-wide training and change efforts." To deliver sensational customer service, you need to have the right culture . Martin says that the right culture: Inspires -- Culture isn't a mission statement; it's a statement of action. Fosters -- When united in a common goal, people contribute to an environment where everybody willingly comes to work each day and pours their best efforts into doing what they believe will make the greatest difference. Transforms -- When working toward a higher purpose, the right culture has a real, positive effect...

Eric Jacobson On Management And Leadership

Search This Blog