Skip to main content

How Higher Education Can Evolve To Meet The Needs Of Next-Generation Learners

 

Kathleen deLaski’s new book, Who Needs Collage Anymore?: Imagining A Future Where Degrees Won’t Matter, offers an optimistic yet practical assessment of how postsecondary education can evolve to meet the needs of next-generation learners. ​She reimagines what higher education might offer and whom it should serve.

This is a must-read for anyone concerned about the future of employment, education, and the economy. deLaski shows that we are on the cusp of a Great College Reset in which workforce training, college, and corporate training become more interchangeable—requiring unprecedented coordination between public, private, and educational institutions and new ways of thinking about the future of work. 

In the wake of declining US university enrollment and widespread crises of confidence in the value of a college degree, deLaski urges a mindset shift regarding the learning routes and credentials that best prepare students for success after high school. 

"Can the four-year degree be saved? Not for most learners, I would argue," says deLaski. "The percentage of adults who believe college is not worth the cost has surged from 42% to 56% in the last decade, and a striking 62% say they prefer short-term skills training and non-degree credentials over traditional degree programs."

deLaski’s book draws on a decade of design-thinking research from the nonprofit Education Design Lab as well as 150 interviews of educational experts, college and career counselors, teachers, employers, and learners. 

She urges institutions to better attend to the needs of new-majority learners, often described as nontraditional students, including people from low- or moderate-income backgrounds, people of color, first-generation students, veterans, single mothers, rural students, part-time attendees, and neurodivergent students. 

Fortunately, she finds ample opportunities for colleges to support learners via alternative pathways to marketable knowledge, including bootcamps, skills-based learning, and apprenticeships, career training, and other types of workplace learning. 

Within the book, deLaski covers: 

The historical context of college degrees and how their perceived value is changing in today's economy—which jobs still need a degree? Which ones don’t? Which industries are making the move? 

Proven alternate pathways to success, including blue- and white-collar apprenticeships and motivated self-starters who use YouTube, Reddit, and webinars to learn valuable coding or marketing skills. 

Ten design principles to redefine college as a place where workforce training, corporate education, and traditional college paths merge and make a flexible and inclusive system for today’s learners. 

 

Kathleen deLaski

deLaski shares these additional insights with us: 

Question: Can the four-year degree be saved? 

DeLaski: Not for most learners, I would argue. Once less expensive alternative pathways become clearer and surer, a full-on degree will seem impractical for new majority learners. And the new majority learners are, by definition, most learners. The four-year degree has been the market signal we’ve led with for almost four hundred years in this country. But why does the degree have to be the only product that colleges sell? And why can’t the American Dream be achieved by other college products, other constructs of career preparation or adultification? 

Question: How do you define “new-majority learners,” and why is it crucial for educational institutions to focus on their needs? 

deLaski: New majority learners is a 21st century way to describe all the types of students for whom college was not designed. And today these students comprise a majority of higher education learners. These are students who not so long ago were excluded from college altogether and who even now find the barriers to success are strong. Some of these groups include Black and brown students, Indigenous students, single parents, students who come from poverty, or live with a disability. They include English language learners, veterans, and anyone who has to work while in college to pay for school. 

Question: What is your message to people who have, for generations, heard that the fastest route to success is a college degree? 

deLaski: The four-year degree is still the default path for families who are not financially constrained. But that’s fewer and fewer people. The good news is that in many fields today, like tech, business, parts of health care, creative arts, you can work your way to professional success by building experience and getting certifications–often without going to college. 

In the book, I provide four profiles of learners who can afford to skip the degree, like the Motivated Self-starter or the Connected Career-Switcher. Succeeding in one of these alternate routes basically depends on four factors: your bankroll, your network, your self-motivation, and choosing a field that doesn’t require a degree. 

Question: What are some successful examples of alternative education pathways or nondegree credentials that you highlight in the book? 

deLaski: Colleges, particularly community colleges, have long offered short-term certificates. And many are now formalizing “micro-pathways” to ready students for specific job role needs in their regions. In fact, a million students a year now go to college to obtain certificates. But these programs, as well as commercially provided bootcamps, are not usually subsidized by student loans or grants. And they should be. Some of the best programs are aimed at lower-income learners, such as YearUp and Merit America. But they rely on employers and philanthropists to fund the model. 

Question: How can colleges and high schools adapt their structure and curriculum to better align with the evolving job market? 

deLaski: Surveys suggest 52% of students who do graduate from college are underemployed, meaning they don’t land jobs that require a degree. Part of it is because employers increasingly say that they want to hire candidates who have experience. A chicken and egg problem. 

So, colleges (and high schools) need to make it their job to help students gain experience. Apprenticeships, internships, even simulated work projects will help students cross the “experience chasm.” This change requires colleges to step up their employer and community engagement departments. One college, Northeastern University, which does this well, has 250 internship facilitators. 

Question: How can families support young adults in making informed decisions about their education and career paths? 

deLaski: I never discourage a young person from attending college if they want that path. If they are feeling ambivalent or anxious, but college won’t break the family bank, I say give it a try, you’ll at least learn what you don’t like. For financially constrained families, I recommend advising your students to earn industry certifications in high school. One fifth of students in community college today are actually high school students taking classes. Apprenticeship programs are starting to gain ground beyond the trades. I profile an insurance company in the book, for example, which starts its apprentices in high school. And community colleges have many short-term certificate programs. These are ways to build your earning power as you decide whether you need more training. 

To gain information on the quality of college programs that are also affordable, I recommend websites such as College Scorecard. 

Question: What challenges do you anticipate in shifting the perception of higher education from traditional degrees to skills-based learning? 

deLaski: The biggest challenge I worry about is less about the perception, but what happens to the broader learning that we lose if our society moves to just-in-time technical skill building. 

If my predictions are correct, that by the mid-century mark only 30% of learners will earn a four-year degree, and students continue to move away from humanities majors, how will we learn about critical thinking—still one of the top requested skills by employers globally. Not to mention civic engagement.

Question: What if colleges, high schools, employers or communities and families want to explore these issues further in their own context? 

deLaski: I’ve provided discussion guides for each of these groups in the book. And I am available to come to regions to help facilitate workshops.

___

deLaski is the founder and board chair of the Education Design Lab, which works with colleges, states, and employers to design shorter, more targeted forms of higher education. 

She also serves as a senior advisor for Harvard's Project on the Workforce and teaches higher ed redesign at George Mason University. 

Thank you to the book’s publisher for sending me an advance copy of the book.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

How To Master The Cycles Of Leadership: The Four Seasons

Whether you’re an aspiring leader, a newly appointed CEO, or a board member wanting to better steward your company’s performance, A CEO For All Seasons: Mastering The Cycles Of Leadership is the hands-on playbook you need – packed with practical, proven tips to help you navigate the four distinct phases of leadership.  “The journey of a CEO has a beginning, middle, and end, and the challenges leaders face early on are often far different than those midway through and near retirement, explain the authors of the book – Carolyn Dewar , Scott Keller , Vikram Malhotra, and Kurt Strovink .   “For us, the most apt analogy to describe these cycles is the four seasons of the year,” they add.  Spring : Stepping up - Preparing for the role. Summer : Transitioning into the role. Starting strong. Leading with impact. Fall : Navigating the middle years. Staying ahead. Sustaining momentum. Enhancing your learning. Future-proofing the organization. Winter : Transitioning out of the rol...

How To Be An Inspirational Leader

Today, I bring back one of my most-read blog posts from 2017. It read as follows: At the end of each year, I select my choice for the  best new leadership book  for that year and then highlight that book on my blog. Well, we're only five months into 2017 and there is a new leadership book so good that I can't wait until year-end to share it with you. And it's likely to be among the select few options for best new leadership book of 2017. It's called,  The Inspiration Code , by  Kristi Hedges . Perhaps now more than any other time, the need for inspirational leadership is critical in the workplace. Filled with profound insights and compelling data and based on a commissioned survey on who and what inspires people, Hedges uncovers a set of consistent, learnable behaviors that dramatically enhance leadership success. And shows you  how to inspire those you lead. And, how to energize people every day . Kristi Hedges But, first, what exactly is inspiration? Hedges ex...

How To Achieve Transformational Success For Leaders

The book,   Reinventing the Leader ,  is an inspiring account of the magic that can happen when a leader realizes they must undergo their own transformation in order to transform their organization.  This candid and practical book by  Guilherme  ( Gui) Loureiro , Regional CEO overseeing Walmex, Walmart Canada, and Walmart Chile (now Chairman of the Board for Walmex and Regional CEO for Canada, Chile, Central America, and Mexico), and his executive leadership coach  Carlos Marin  shows how even the most successful leaders must be open to personal change in order to transform their company. The book details how the pair pioneered a data-driven, customer-centric business transformation at Walmex—Walmart’s biggest division outside of the United States. “This book is a blueprint for transformational success for leaders in any business who find themselves facing the need to retool their own company’s systems and operations and energize and inspire an entire ...

How To Become A Leader

Here’s another must-read book to add to your list as you transition from manager to leader. It’s  The Leap to Leader , by  Adam Bryant . As the creator of the iconic “Corner Office” column in the  New York Times , Bryant has spoken with more than a thousand leaders over the years about the challenges and nuances of leadership. Many of his discussions are included in his interview series on LinkedIn.  “The goal of this book is to provide an intensely practical guide to making that transition by sharing insights, stories, and approaches from hundreds of leaders to build the skills you will need to make the leap to leader,” explains Bryant.   He adds that the book is useful to everyone who is interested in leadership, regardless of where they are in their career.   The book covers:   The central paradox of leaders: selfless vs. self-centered. How to perfect the do-to-say ratio. Ways to navigate office politics. Tactics to making better decisions. The cruc...

How To Lead Bigger

Anne Chow ’s book,  Lead Bigger , is about “where it all comes together.” By that, she means: Being driven by a compelling purpose and values, which are not platitudes, but rather lived. The goals are better decisions, improved performance, and ultimately a greater impact. Impact means you have the power to make real and enduring change for the better. Widening your perspective to have a greater performance and impact. Advancing work that matters. Developing a vital, innovative workforce that is both trusted and agile. Championing flexibility by embracing trust and empowerment for individuals, teams, and leaders alike.   Drawing from over three decades of experience, former CEO of AT&T Business Chow shares that leading bigger also means:   Embracing the whole of your team beyond the workplace : Seeing the value and potential of each individual—in the context of not only their work, but also their life.   Engaging in self-reflection : Demonstrating self-awareness ...

How To Reframe Healthy Risk For Greater Achievement

“Facing rapid change and rising uncertainty, risk can feel intimidating, overwhelming, and even paralyzing. Yet a culture of safety, where risk is seen as dangerous, can flatten growth and spur stagnation,” explains Ben Swire , author of the new book, Safe Danger: An Unexpected Method For Sparking Connection, Finding Purpose, And Inspiring Innovation .  “We all crave inspiring experiences, meaningful work, and deeper relationships. But getting there requires risk,” adds Swire.  Swire is an award-winning designer, IDEO (A Global Design & Innovation Company) veteran, and team builder and in his book, he shows how to reframe healthy risk for greater achievement, supercharging employee engagement, and creating more innovative workplaces.  Whether you're a leader looking to engage your team, a professional seeking to infuse your career with new life, or an individual striving to get more out of your time each day, Safe Danger offers the tools and insights you need to help...

10 Quotes From The 5 Levels Of Leadership -- John C. Maxwell

Soon I'll post my full review of John C. Maxwell's latest book, The 5 Levels of Leadership .  In the meantime, here are some of my favorites quotes from the book that I believe should become a must-read book by any workplace/organizational leader: Good leadership isn't about advancing yourself.  It's about advancing your team. Leaders become great, not because of their power, but because of their ability to empower others. Leadership is action, not position. When people feel liked, cared for, included, valued, and trusted, they begin to work together with their leader and each other. If you have integrity with people, you develop trust.  The more trust you develop, the stronger the relationship becomes.  In times of difficulty, relationships are a shelter.  In times of opportunity, they are a launching pad. Good leaders must embrace both care and candor. People buy into the leader, then the vision. Bringing out the best in a person is often a catal...

How To Find The Job You Love

In 2024, I named Be The Unicorn: Data-driven Habits That Separate The Best Leaders From The Rest , by William Vanderbloemen , as the best new leadership book of that year.   The book is timely, incredibly practical, and immediately usable for any leader wherever they are on their leadership journey.   Through extensive research of more than 30,000 top leaders and proprietary data, Vanderbloemen identified in the book the twelve habits that the best of the best leaders have in common. These superstar leaders are the unicorns – highly desirable but that are difficult to find or obtain.   And now, Vanderbloemen followed up that gem of a book with another terrific book called, Work How You Are Wired: 12 Data-Driven Steps To Finding A Job You Love . It’s a great companion book to Be The Unicorn .   Those 12 steps align with these 12 personality traits/interpersonal habits: Fast Authentic Agile Solver Anticipator Prepared Self-aware Curious Connected Likeable Producti...

How To Align Sales And Marketing To Drive Company Success

Nearly 90 percent of startups will fail without ever reaching a point of positive return on investment. Founders and entrepreneurs are facing unprecedented challenges in pursuit of becoming one of the coveted 10 percent.   Who better to turn to for advice than the duo behind the most successful software IPO in history?   That is where Denise Persson and Chris Degnan come in, authors of the new book, Make It Snow .   During the nearly nine years they worked together at Snowflake, they built  one of the longest-running and most effective sales-marketing partnerships from the ground up, unifying  two historically divided groups in corporate America. Together, they took Snowflake from struggling startup to a tech powerhouse on par with Google and Amazon. Over the years, Snowflake surged to more than 9,000 employes and $3 billion in annual sales.   “Sales and marketing are often neglected in startups, with focus squarely placed on the engineerin...

Effective Listening: Do's And Don'ts

Here are some great tips from Michelle Tillis Lederman's book, The 11 Laws of Likability .  They are all about: what to do and what not to do to be a leader who's an effective listener : Do : Maintain eye contact Limit your talking Focus on the speaker Ask questions Manage your emotions Listen with your eyes and ears Listen for ideas and opportunities Remain open to the conversation Confirm understanding, paraphrase Give nonverbal messages that you are listening (nod, smile) Ignore distractions Don't : Interrupt Show signs of impatience Judge or argue mentally Multitask during a conversation Project your ideas Think about what to say next Have expectations or preconceived ideas Become defensive or assume you are being attacked Use condescending, aggressive, or closed body language Listen with biases or closed to new ideas Jump to conclusions or finish someone's sentences