How To Improve The Way Teams Think, Collaborate And Make Decisions Under Pressure

“Great decisions don’t happen by accident—they happen by design,” shares Dr. Ricardo Valerdi, author of the new book, The Five-Tool Team: Bringing Out The Best In People To Make Better Decisions.

This book is not about finding perfect answers. It is about building a framework that allows you to make good decisions repeatedly, even when conditions are imperfect, information is incomplete, and outcomes are uncertain.

More specifically, Valerdi reveals a practical framework for improving the way individuals and teams think, collaborate, and make decisions under pressure.

Drawing on lessons from sports, business, engineering, and real-world experience, Valerdi shows how the most effective leaders build teams that question assumptions, analyze consequences, and make choices grounded in clarity rather than instinct or urgency.

“Writing this book has been a phenomenal journey that started in 2018 when I was a visiting professor at the United States Military Academy at West Point,” says Valerdi. “The initial concept for the book was aimed at helping army cadets make better decisions. This evolved into the stories and examples from college athletics, software development, fraud detection, healthcare, and socioemotional learning.”

Valerdi explains that we control our decisions, not their outcomes. He clarifies that outcomes may vary, but the discipline of decision-making is ours to master. If decisions are the part we control and outcomes are the part we cannot, then the real opportunity is to invest energy toward improving the act of deciding itself.

Furthermore, says Valerdi, judging decisions by their outcomes is a trap because outcomes are influenced by factors beyond our control, like chance, timing, and external forces. In his words, “A well-reasoned decision can lead to a disappointing result, just as a poor decision can occasionally yield success by sheer luck. If we measure quality by outcome alone, we reward randomness and punish rigor.”

In addition, shares Valerdi, decisions don’t happen in a single moment; they unfold in phases, each one shaping the quality of the choice we ultimately make. Like a coach preparing a team for a game or an executive guiding a company through a strategic move, you can approach decision-making as a four-stage process: sensemaking, option generation, option evaluation, and selection.

Sensemaking is about gathering context, so the decision isn’t made in a vacuum. In business, it’s a manager scanning market trends, customer feedback, and competitor moves to grasp the environment.

Option generation is about creativity and ensuring you have choices on the table. Once the objectives are defined, the next step is to create possible plays. In business, a product team might brainstorm several strategies to launch a new service.

Option evaluation is where critical thinking filters the possibilities down to the most viable ones. Not all plays or strategies are equal. In business, leaders compare options by analyzing costs, benefits, and risks.

Selection involves commitment from the decision-maker and the team. For example, the regional sales manager chooses the market-entry strategy. This is the moment of action, where intent becomes reality. It is the culmination of the process: the point where preparation and analysis give way to execution.

Think of the decision-making process as a game of four quarters. Each quarter builds on the last and skipping one leaves the team without a game plan. Decision-making is a complete game, not a single play.

As you read the book, you’ll also learn how to create The Five-Tool Team where each of the five tools is a practical skill you can infuse into your team’s culture, strengthening the way you work and lead. Together, they build the foundation of a Five-Tool Team, equipped to rise to challenges, trust its own judgment, and make confident, high‑quality decisions. The five tools are:

Focus on the Questions: what, when, who, how, and why.
Look at the Data from Multiple Perspectives.
Analyze the Consequences.
Scrutinize the Options.
Humanize it.

“Together, these five tools form the acronym FLASH. However, this doesn’t mean decisions should be made quickly. Quite the opposite,” explains Valerdi. “Important decisions deserve more time and energy than they typically get. FLASH represents the flash of brilliance that can illuminate a problem in an unexpected way. Brilliance requires openness to new ways of thinking and a willingness to believe there is always room for improvement.”

The FLASH tools are not a rigid sequence either. They are flexible resources you can draw upon whenever the situation demands. It often makes sense to begin by focusing on the right questions (Tool #1), but the next step might be to analyze consequences (Tool #3) or scrutinize options (Tool #4). The order depends on how complex the challenge is and the gaps that need to be filled. Think of these tools as instruments in a well-stocked toolbox. The value is in knowing which tool to reach for when it is most needed.

For leaders ready to adopt the Five-Tool Team approach, you can use this handy FLASH checklist:

F—Focus on the Questions
What needs to be decided?
Who decides? By when?
Who needs to be involved and informed?

L—Look at the Data from Multiple Perspectives
Gather evidence from at least three sources.
Ask: What else could be true?
Invite one dissenting voice.

A—Analyze the Consequences
Intended outcomes?
Unintended ripple effects?
Positive and negative second-order impacts?

S—Scrutinize the Options
Generate at least three viable options.
Stress-test assumptions.
Apply the Tenth Man Rule: If everyone agrees, challenge the consensus.

H—Humanize It
Blend instinct with evidence.
Explain the decision in plain language.
Simplify complexity and build trust.

Other key takeaways from the book include:

As you build your Five-Tool Team, remember that you don’t need a single superstar. You need a roster. Rate your team on the rubric to find the gaps.

Assign roles by letting the curious one lead the questions, the skeptic hunt for blind spots, and the storyteller make complexity simple. Your team’s effectiveness multiplies when these strengths are combined.

To create this culture within your team, commit to the following ideals:

Reward curiosity.
Normalize dissent.
Separate decision quality from outcome.
Celebrate learning from mistakes.
Simplify complexity.

Once a decision is made, the team must get behind it fully. Healthy debate belongs in the discussion phase, but hesitation during execution can derail everything. Teams don’t move forward with half‑hearted support. They move forward with people who understand what was decided and why it matters.

Packed with stories, tools, and simple habits that create lasting impact, The Five-Tool Team is the essential tool kit for transforming decision-making from an individual skill into a team advantage.

Dr. Ricardo Valerdi

Valerdi shares this final insight with us:

Question: Of the five FLASH tools, which do most teams struggle with and why?

Valerdi: Of the five FLASH tools, the one that teams often struggle with the most is Tool #4: Scrutinize the Options. Ironically, most people are quite comfortable scrutinizing the ideas, assumptions, and recommendations of others. What is much harder is turning that same level of scrutiny inward and critically examining our own thinking.

All-Star decision makers possess the humility to recognize that they may not have all the information, that their assumptions could be flawed, or that they might be heading down the wrong path. Self-scrutiny requires intellectual honesty and the willingness to question conclusions that we have already become emotionally invested in.

This is why Tool #4 is so challenging. Once we commit to a course of action, confirmation bias can take over, causing us to seek evidence that supports our position while ignoring warning signs. Sometimes it takes a trusted colleague or friend to deliver a reality check and help us see what we are missing. This is like having someone "slap us in the face" and remind us that it's time to abandon the Titanic before it sinks.
___
Valerdi is an engineer, social entrepreneur, sports scientist, and engineering professor at the University of Arizona. Through his work developing teams that think clearly and decide confidently, he has helped a variety of organizations make better decisions, including SpaceX, the US Army, Major League Baseball, and the National Collegiate Athletic Association.

He is also a passionate advocate for STEM education for young learners. He founded the nonprofit Science of Sport, which has impacted over seven hundred thousand students by reframing math and science through the lens of sports.

Thank you to the book’s publisher for sending me an advance copy of the book.

Comments

How To Build A High Performing Sales Team

Based on Stephanie Friedman 's 20 years of sales experience, her new book, Built to Grow: A Handbook For High-Performance Sales Teams , is the perfect step-by-step, go-to-market field guide for startup founders. Friedman offers readers a structured and repeatable methodology for building a high-performing sales function from a company’s earliest days. The book is divided into three phases of startup growth— Experiment, Build, and Scale. Within each of the three phases, Friedman covers: Sales Playbook Hiring Revenue Management Customer Success Compensations Culture Internal Collaboration Some of my favorite takeaway tips from the book include: No matter how experienced your salespeople are, any high-performing sales organization should follow one simple but important rule: No call without an agenda. This helps reinforce the necessary discipline around call preparation and ensures your customers have the best possible experience when talking to your...

High-Performing Teams Are Made Of This

According to Ron Ricci and Carl Wiese, authors of the book, The Collaboration Imperative , high-performing teams have the following characteristics: People have solid and deep trust in each other and in the team's purpose--they feel free to express feelings and ideas. Everybody is working toward the same goals. Team members are clear on how to work together and how to accomplish tasks. Everyone understands both team and individual performance goals and knows what is expected. Team members actively diffuse tension and friction in a relaxed and informal atmosphere. The team engages in extensive discussion, and everyone gets a chance to contribute--even the introverts. Disagreement is viewed as a good thing and conflicts are managed. Criticism is constructive and is oriented toward problem solving and removing obstacles. The team makes decisions when there is natural agreement--in the cases where agreement is elusive, a decision is made by the team lead or executiv...

Decide

Many years ago, I worked with a person who could not make decisions. Neither big nor small decisions. That indecisiveness paralyzed our business in many ways. Unfortunately, the book, Decide: Work Smarter, Reduce Your Stress, and Lead by Example , had not been published. Had it, I would have shared it with my co-worker. Decide , published this past February, teaches readers how to make better decisions based on the real results they want to experience. The author, Steve McClatchy, explains how to use the two forms of human motivation -- Gain, or Prevent Pain , to make more effective decisions. For example, he demonstrates how inserting a Gain task in the middle of a Prevent Pain day can give you the energy you need to move forward and make the Prevent Pain tasks take less time through motivation. Deeper into the book, you'll be reminded about not only the problems with procrastination, but also about the benefits of procrastination, and, if you are ...

Coherence: The Secret Science Of Brilliant Leadership

Coherence: The Secret Science of Brilliant Leadership is the new book by author Dr. Alan Watkins . Trained as a medical doctor, Watkins is now an honorary senior lecturer in neuroscience and psychological medicine at Imperial College, London and an affiliate professor of leadership at the European School of Management, London. According to Watkins, coherence is the biological state achieved when elite performers experience maximum efficiency and super effectiveness, where body and mind are one . Coherence provides one of the most unique approaches to showing leaders how to be younger, smarter, healthier and happier -- which gives them the power to make decisions under pressure and achieve sustainable success. Prepare to spend quality time reading Coherence . It's not light reading. Kind of feels like a medical text book in parts. But, it's worth your commitment to it. I particularly found useful Watkin's discussion on culture , where he w...

5 Compelling Benefits Of Having An Ethical Culture

In Andrew Leigh's book, Ethical Leadership , he provides these compelling and important benefits of having an ethical culture in your business/organization: Customers prefer dealing with companies who put ethics at the center of their culture. Most employees would prefer to earn less working for an ethical company than being paid more and working for an unethical company. More than one in three people at work say they've left a job because they've disagreed with the company's ethical standards ( Trevino, L and Nelson, K - 2011 ) If you adopt an early warning system against misconduct it reduces the risk of you facing expensive litigation. An ethical culture helps you make your company a strong affirming place to work in. "The foundations of an ethical culture include values, attitudes, meaning, behaviors, purpose, and management practices," explains Leigh.

More Leadership Quotes From John C. Maxwell

The real gems in John C. Maxwell's book, Everyone Communicates Few Connect , book are the abundant leadership and communication quotes, such as these: To add value to others, one must first value others. People may hear your words, but they feel your attitude. All good communicators get to the point before their listeners start asking, "What's the point?" The first time you say something, it's heard. The second time, it's recognized, and the third time it's learned. In the end, people are persuaded not by what we say, but by what they understand. People pay attention when something that is said connects with something they greatly desire. Maxwell also says that: Management is about persuading people to do things they do not want to do, while leadership is about inspiring people to do things they never thought they could . The book covers five principles and five practices to help readers so they can connect one-on-one, in a group, or...

Six-pillar Roadmap For How To Move From Merely Surviving To Truly Mattering

In the new book, The Mattering Effect: Creating A Life Of Meaning And Worth , podcaster and author John R. Miles reframes today’s most common struggles and empowers individuals and institutions alike to break bad habits and reclaim a sense of worth and belonging. “Organizations have spent the last decade chasing 'engagement' and 'psychological safety,' yet global productivity is stalling and 60% of employees report they do not feel valued in the places where they spend their days,” shares Miles. He calls this “The Great Erasure”—a condition where high-achievers become highly visible to the organization while becoming invisible to themselves. In addition, Miles argues that many of today’s most common struggles—burnout, anxiety, loneliness, and disengagement—are not personal failures or mindset problems. They are the result of unmattering: the gradual erosion of felt significance within modern systems that reward performance while overlooking presence. Fortu...

Make It Easy For Your Employees To Volunteer

Start planning now for this year's National Volunteer Week, April 15-21 . That's the week when nonprofit organizations throughout the U.S. will celebrate and honor their volunteers. If you are not already volunteering, what a great time to start. Make a commitment to yourself to start volunteering before that week starts! And, if you are a workplace leader who supports a volunteer program at your business, you already know that by encouraging employees to give back to your community you are: building teamwork motivating employees attracting new hires In fact, job seekers much prefer companies that have a strong volunteer program. And, a growing number of businesses are rewarding employees who volunteer by giving them extra vacation time and other incentives. Fortunately, throughout the U.S. there are hundreds of volunteer opportunities where employees can contribute individually, or where leaders can organize teams of employees to volunteer together on a routin...

How To Make One Bold Move A Day

Shanna A. Hocking ’s new book, One Bold Move A Day , is all about meaningful actions women can take to fulfill their leadership and career potential. Specially, Hocking reveals the transformative mindsets needed to make one Bold Move a day. Those are: Gratitude Mindset And Mindset Happiness Mindset Progress Mindset “Each of these four mindsets individually plays a special role in the process of continuously showing up for yourself and others,” explains Hocking. “Each mindset contributes in a different way to your success, but they all complement each other and together they will become the foundation to your Bold Move Mindset.” Hocking explains in her book that a Bold Move is one that challenges you to grow . “Sometimes it’s about capitalizing on an opportunity, and sometimes it’s about creating that opportunity for yourself,” explains Hocking. Keep in mind, too, that a Bold Move for you might not be the same as someone else’s. ...

3 Things To Avoid When You Give Your Next Speech

If you don't want to get your speech off to a bad start, the communications experts at Speechworks suggest you: Don't apologize (particularly about your anxiety or lack of preparation. Apologies put your audience on the defensive. Don't start by telling a joke (which may not be all that funny, or is irrelevant, or that may even be offensive to someone in your audience). Don't beat around the bush (including, don't list off a lot of people you want to thank. Don't waste your audience's valuable time) Instead: If you need to deal with your anxiety, practice like crazy . Rehearse particularly your first line over and over. Start your presentation by laying out for your audience a key issue that they are facing in their business . If you must thank someone, do it at the end, or thank your introducer briefly, pause, and then start right into the meat of your message .

Eric Jacobson On Management And Leadership

Search This Blog