Skip to main content

The Power Of Middle Managers In The Workplace

The book, Power To The Middle, shows how managers are the crucial link between a company’s ground floor and top brass. “Too often company leaders view middle managers in a negative light as expendable employees who can slow down productivity and overall strategy,” explain the book’s authors and McKinsey partners Bill SchaningerBryan Hancock, and Emily Field

“However, new KcKinsey research reveals that this outdated perspective needs to change and that well-developed managers are the strategy that companies must prioritize to succeed today,” they add. 

Most importantly, by the end of their book, the authors sum up their insights and provide a playbook that will help senior leaders let go of the command-and-control mindset that has hobbled their managers for so long. 

The authors define middle managers as the people who are at least once removed from the front line and at least a layer below the senior leadership. From this pivotal position, a middle manager’s job is to bring out the best in their people, and in that way bring out the best in their organizations. 

“With the right training and practice, middle managers are in the best position to evaluate employee performance and provide feedback that’s continuous rather than just a pro forma yearly review meant to create a paper trail,” share the authors. 

Further, middle managers manage both up and down, and serve as critical translators in both directions. 

“Only managers can offer the day-to-day sense of purpose, belonging, and identify that many workers crave,” claim the authors. “And, only those managers can craft the types of tailored—as opposed to one-size-fits-all—working arrangements that will aid in both recruitment and retention.” 

To get the most from middle managers, the authors advise positioning and preparing them to:

  • Be the face of an organization’s war for talent with vital people skills to both attract and retain top performers.
  • Build their organization’s knowledge and realign it with shifts from digital disruption.
  • Pivot from enforcing antiquated, inefficient organizational rules to challenging them.
  • Advance in title and compensation but not be promoted outside of any manager role, where they’ll make the most impact.
  • Focus on people rather than procedures.
  • Clarify each team member’s goals with a deep understanding of how their unique skills and strengths can contribute to the company’s long-term goals.
  • Provide frequent and nonjudgmental feedback to help each team member achieve their best performance.

Emily Field

 

Bryan Hancock

 

Bill Schaninger

The authors share these additional insights with us:

Question: Why are middle managers uniquely positioned to impact an organization’s daily performance and overall strategic success? 

The Authors: Middle managers are the vital link between senior leaders and those on the frontline. They are in an ideal place to see how an organization’s purpose, strategy, and culture are trickling down into the organization and whether they’re actually working. They can inform all three in return. 

Managers are also the most important guides needed to help teams and organizations navigate the seismic challenges in today’s world of work, including automation, hybrid work, and skill shortages. They are also best positioned to forge the day-to-day human connections that so many workers crave, and critical to improving DE&I, retaining and developing talent, and more. 

Question: For companies to succeed in this new world of work, what responsibilities and authority should managers be given? 

The Authors: Middle managers can only perform their roles well if they are set up to succeed—which means giving them the space and training they need to excel as people managers. Too often, they find themselves drowning in administrative work or extra tasks requested by more senior leaders. Indeed, a recent McKinsey survey found that middle managers are, on average, spending almost three-quarters of their time on tasks other than managing their teams. 

If senior leaders can free managers to focus primarily on their people, however, the organization will reap the benefits. Successful middle managers create strong human connections within their organizations and ensure all team members have the resources they need. As the filter between senior leadership and the front line, the modern middle manager should be a coach, connector, talent manager, and strategist. 

Question: You say it’s crucial that managers be rewarded for their work but not promoted out of their positions. How can companies achieve this? 

The Authors: Promotion is a lever companies can pull to reward middle managers, but it’s not the only one. Because of their ability to foster talent and connect people across teams, many of the best middle managers are most fulfilled and valuable at the center of the action. 

Senior leaders should do everything they can to reward and retain great middle managers in their current roles, including providing additional flexibility, better salaries and bonuses, ambitious and purposeful assignments, continuous learning and development opportunities and training, recognition and gratitude, etc.  

By contrast, not everyone is well-suited to be a middle manager. Companies should offer expert tracks for those employees who want to go deep into content and subject matter expertise as opposed to leading people. Both paths should be recognized as critical to the organization as they perform necessary, but different, functions. 

Question: What are the four modern roles for senior leaders in today’s workplace and how do they help managers succeed? 

The Authors: The success of business leadership has typically been viewed through the lens of shareholders, but now, the list of stakeholders has expanded to encompass employees, customers, suppliers, partners, and more. This evolution has led to the creation of what we consider the four modern leadership roles: VisionaryArchitectCoach, and Catalyst

These four roles complement each other and create a new organizational dynamic where leaders’ power is shared with managers, who in turn share it with their reports. With the traditional “command-and-control” style of leadership replaced by a mindset focused on talent management, senior leaders’ personal success is often driven by the success of those below them. 

Thank you to the book’s publisher for sending me an advance copy of the book. 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Effective Listening: Do's And Don'ts

Here are some great tips from Michelle Tillis Lederman's book, The 11 Laws of Likability .  They are all about: what to do and what not to do to be a leader who's an effective listener : Do : Maintain eye contact Limit your talking Focus on the speaker Ask questions Manage your emotions Listen with your eyes and ears Listen for ideas and opportunities Remain open to the conversation Confirm understanding, paraphrase Give nonverbal messages that you are listening (nod, smile) Ignore distractions Don't : Interrupt Show signs of impatience Judge or argue mentally Multitask during a conversation Project your ideas Think about what to say next Have expectations or preconceived ideas Become defensive or assume you are being attacked Use condescending, aggressive, or closed body language Listen with biases or closed to new ideas Jump to conclusions or finish someone's sentences

Seven Tough Questions To Ask Your Team

  High-functioning teams can disagree and still produce excellent products and results. Team members can also disagree and still care about each other. And, they can challenge each other to think differently. Best-selling leadership book authors  Scott J. Allen  and  Mitchell Kusy  recommend that leaders ask seven tough questions of their teams to help maximize their results. Here are those questions to ask each team member: What are some obstacles  affecting this team? What are opportunities  we could take advantage of that we have been largely ignoring? Where can you take greater ownership  on this team? Where have you let this team down ? Compared to other teams with which you are familiar,  how are we doing ? When was the last time you complimented the team  or one of its members? How open are you to giving direct feedback  to team members?

70 New Year's Resolutions For Leaders

With 2025 fast approaching, it's a good time to identify your New Year's Resolutions for next year. To get you started, how about selecting one or more of the following 70 New Year's resolutions for leaders? Perhaps write down five to ten and then between now and January 1, think about which couple you want to work on during 2025. Don't micromanage Don't be a bottleneck Focus on outcomes, not minutiae Build trust with your colleagues before a crisis comes Assess your company's strengths and weaknesses at all times Conduct annual risk reviews Be courageous, quick and fair Talk more about values more than rules Reward how a performance is achieved and not only the performance Constantly challenge your team to do better Celebrate your employees' successes, not your own Err on the side of taking action Communicate clearly and often Be visible Eliminate the cause of a mistake View every problem as an opportunity to grow Summarize group consensus after each decisi...

How To Build Great Work Relationships

Here is a new book I wish was published back when I was early in my career. It’s called,  Bosses, Coworkers, and Building Great Work Relationships . It’s one of four books in the new  Harvard Business Review  ( HBR )  Work Smart Series .  The book includes adapted content from 20 articles that previously appeared on HBR.org.  “We probably spend more hours with our coworkers than with anyone else. So even if they’re not all perfect, it’s worth it to build connections that will provide you with support, help you network and learn, and keep your career moving forward,” shares HBR.  “This book helps readers make so-so work relationships better, keep the bad ones from bringing them down, and help them build lasting connections with incredible people.”  HBR adds that the book includes chapter takeaways and dozens of resources so that you can go beyond the book to engage in the media (video, audio, etc.) you learn from best.  As you read Bosses,...

How To Use Failure To Succeed

“On the path to success, we trip and lose our footing from time to time. But stumbling and even falling is the best way to learn from mistakes and is critical to achieving goals,” says  Bill Wooditch , author of the book,  Fail More: Embrace, Learn, And, Adapt to Failure As A Way To Success . “We all fail. It’s a part of business, and it’s a part of life,” explains Wooditch. “It’s how you deal with setbacks is what makes the difference.” The book will teach you how to: Conquer the negative emotions that naturally arise after making mistakes. Clearly articulate lessons learned. Put these lessons to use immediately.  Plus, you’ll learn how to: Navigate all forms of rejection and failure in pragmatic ways. Rationally examine your personal fears and gain mastery over them. Shed the discomfort of uncertainty, which is the only way to open your mind to all possibilities.  Wooditch answers these questions for us about failing, succeeding and his book: Question :  We ar...

How To Be A Learn-It-All Leader

“Great leaders are great students, and the world is their classroom,” says   Damon Lembi , author of the new book   The Learn-It-all Leader .  “Learn-It-All leaders are constantly creating and re-creating themselves, their companies, and their leadership. They are information extractors. They pull what they learn about everything—be it product innovation or how to inspire a team—from their lived experience,” adds Lembi.  These types of leaders also model and directly encourage a culture of learning inside their organizations. This attracts higher-quality workers, improves their performance over time and holds onto them longer.  The book is divided into two parts: Part 1:  Being  –  explores how Learn-It-All leaders think . Part 2:  Doing  –  examines what Learn-It-All leaders do differently .  Damon Lembi Some of my favorite takeaways (including some quotes) from the book include:  Quote : “Live as if you were to die tomor...

How To Be A Collaborative Leader

Edward M. Marshall 's book,  Transforming The Way We Work -- The Power Of The Collaborative Workplace , remains relevant today, two decades after Marshall wrote it. Particularly useful is the book's section that teaches readers  how to be a collaborative leader . Marshall says that there are  seven different, important roles and responsibilities of collaborative leaders when leading teams , and those leaders should select the appropriate style to meet the team's needs. The seven roles are : The leader as sponsor  -- You provide strategic direction, boundaries and coaching for the team. You also monitor progress and ensure integrity in the team's operating processes. The leader as facilitator  -- You ensure that meetings, team dynamics, and interpersonal relationships function effectively. You also ensure internal coordination of activities among team members. The leader as coach  -- You provide support and guidance and you serve as a sounding board. The lea...

How To Fix The 12 Most Common Presentation Mistakes

Here is a must-read book for anyone who makes presentations at work, a club, a non-profit, or to any group of individuals the presenter wants to persuade to take action.   The book is,  Presentation Ready , by  Terri L. Sjodin , one of America’s leading experts on persuasive presentations. Her specialty is blending communications theory, field research, and practical sales experience to help professionals and non-professionals become more polished and persuasive presenters.   When you read the book, you’ll discover the  12 common sales presentations mistakes  and you’ll learn why the mistakes happen, why the mistakes are damaging, and how to avoid the mistakes.  Presentation Ready  is divided into three sections:   Building your case  – the foundation of your persuasive arguments and content. Leveraging creativity  – How your persuasive message resonates with listeners (storytelling, visual aids, structure, curiosity) Honing your de...

6 Ways To Seek Feedback To Improve Your Performance In The Workplace

Getting feedback is an important way to improve performance at work. But sometimes, it can be hard to seek out, and even harder to hear.  “Feedback is all around you. Your job is to find it, both through asking directly and observing it,” says David L. Van Rooy, author of the new book,  Trajectory: 7 Career Strategies to Take You From Where You Are to Where You Want to Be . As today's guest post, Van Rooy offers these  six tips for how to get the feedback you need to improve performance at work . Guest Post By David L. Van Rooy 1.       Don’t forget to as k :  One of the biggest mistakes people make is assuming things are going perfectly (until they make a catastrophic mistake). By not asking, you’re missing out on opportunities for deep feedback: the difficult, critical feedback that gives you constructive ways to improve. 2.       Make sure you listen :  Remember, getting fee...

10 Quotes From The 5 Levels Of Leadership -- John C. Maxwell

Soon I'll post my full review of John C. Maxwell's latest book, The 5 Levels of Leadership .  In the meantime, here are some of my favorites quotes from the book that I believe should become a must-read book by any workplace/organizational leader: Good leadership isn't about advancing yourself.  It's about advancing your team. Leaders become great, not because of their power, but because of their ability to empower others. Leadership is action, not position. When people feel liked, cared for, included, valued, and trusted, they begin to work together with their leader and each other. If you have integrity with people, you develop trust.  The more trust you develop, the stronger the relationship becomes.  In times of difficulty, relationships are a shelter.  In times of opportunity, they are a launching pad. Good leaders must embrace both care and candor. People buy into the leader, then the vision. Bringing out the best in a person is often a catal...